I’m a nationally published sleep expert, journalist, and the mom of three young kids. I’ve been helping tired families sleep since 2007 (more about me here). Subscribe to The Well Rested Family for fresh news and tips on keeping your bunch happy and healthy. Thanks for stopping by!

SEARCH THIS BLOG

Find Me Here!

Tag cloud
10 month old sleep 11 month old 2 year old can't fall asleep 2 year old nap 3 year old stops napping 4 month old 45 minute naps 8 month old adults adults sleep alarm clock babies baby baby bedtime baby doesn't nap baby fall back baby nursing to sleep baby rolling at night baby short naps baby sleep baby sleep positioners baby sleep routine bad bedtimes bedroom too loud bedsharing bedtime bedtime baby bedtime books bedtime child bedtime for teens bedtime problem bedtime routine bedtime snacks bedtimes bedwetting best bedtime stories for kids big boy bed blackout curtains boost breastfed baby sleep through the night bsby cosleeping bumpers caffeine child child bedtime child can't sleep child sleeping in a tent childcare childhood fears and sleep children cosleeping cover story creativity crib cry it out cultural intelligence daycare daylight savings time Daylight Savings Time kid bedtime daylight savings time sleep DHA does exercise help kids sleep dropping a nap DST early waker early waking ebook education energy equality equally shared parenting exercise and kids exercise and sleep fall back falling back families family five month old naps five month old short naps five month old sleep five year old bedtime food getting baby to bed getting dad to help with bedtime Getting kids to bed getting kids to bed during the summer getting kids to bed when it's light out getting rid of the pacifier giveaway green Harvey Karp Hawaii health heart health tips help helping kids adjust to daylight savings time helping kids get to sleep after vacation Helping kids sleep in the summer helping kids sleep through the night helping twins sleep holiday how long should babies nap how long should bedtime take how much sleep do adults need how to get rid of nightmares how to help a preschooler nap how to stop nightmares humor immune system infant sleep insomnia kids kids always get sick kids and daylight savings time kids sharing bedrooms kids sleep questions Kindle king 5 large family late bedtime learning leg cramps light math Moms moving child to his own bedroom nap nap routine napping in arms naps new sibling newborn news night terror night waking nightlights nightmare nightmares nighttime dryness nurse to sleep association nutrition one year old overtied kids overtired overtired child overtiredness pacifier pajamas nightmares parenting parentmap pediatric restless legs syndrome potty training pregnancy and newborn preschool Preschooler problem problem solving product productivity pull ups putting kids to bed questions raising a boy robotic safety safey separation anxiety setting a bedtime for kids shared bedroom shared bedrooms Shopping short naps short sleeper six month old sleep skipped naps sleep sleep and learning sleep coach sleep coaching sleep consulting sleep expert sleep for moms sleep gadgets sleep help sleep hygiene sleep pregnancy sleep questions sleep regression sleep through the night sleeping during the summer sleeping well during pregnancy sleeping while camping soundproof spring forward standing and screaming in crib stress sugar summer summer bedtime swaddle teen teen bedtime Teenage brains television time change time zone adjustment toddler toddler 4 am toddler bed toddler leg cramps toddler naps toddler sleep toddlers toilet transition transition to one nap travel with kids tryptophan twins undertired up all night violence and kids violent video games and children waking warm bedroom hurts sleep weaning the swaddle winter women heart health won't fall asleep work worries
« Congratulations! | Main | Staying Well-Rested With Nine Children: An Interview With Erika Shupe »
Thursday
Nov102011

Bye-bye, Bumpers: Should the Government Ban Crib Bumpers?

They’re soft, inviting, and adorable, and many new parents can’t imagine a crib without them—but crib bumpers may soon become a thing of the past. This fall, Chicago became the first US city to ban the sale of crib bumpers. Maryland is the first state to seriously consider a state-wide ban, but it certainly won’t be the last.

In September, the Baltimore Sun called the potential ban “a smart public health policy that's also likely to save lives.” Nationwide, 27 deaths have been attributed to crib bumpers over the past two decades. Health experts say the real number of casualties is probably much higher, because crib bumpers are likely suspects in many more SIDS deaths.

But bumpers pose another potential health risk that I haven’t seen discussed in the media: they can give an intrepid toddler a leg up in climbing out of his or her crib. Back before the days of bumper bans, my oldest daughter used hers as a means of escape. Her thick Pottery Barn bumper gave her just the boost she needed to get out of the crib so she could do a little midnight exploring around the house. Needless to say, we promptly removed the bumper, and moved her to a toddler bed soon afterward.

Though the bans are intended to promote public safety, they're controversial. Get a bunch of parents talking, and you’ll find that bumpers have a quite a few fans, despite their potential safety drawbacks. Many parents don’t see what the fuss is all about--their kids used bumpers and turned out fine. For me, the biggest benefit to crib bumpers was the way that they kept pacifiers in the crib instead of on the floor.

So, I’m wondering: When will everyone give bumpers the heave-ho? Though doctors and health officials are urging parents not to use them, many still are. And major retailers like Pottery Barn are still selling them, so that means people are still buying them. Are parents simply ignoring the warnings, or are they unaware or unconvinced of the risks?

Do you think the government should ban bumpers, or leave the decision up to parents? What do you think?

References (7)

References allow you to track sources for this article, as well as articles that were written in response to this article.
  • Response
    Response: unique clocks
    Writer, Editor, & Sleep Journalist - The Well Rested Family - Bye-bye, Bumpers: Should the Government Ban Crib Bumpers?
  • Response
    Response: cooking light
    Writer, Editor, & Sleep Journalist - The Well Rested Family - Bye-bye, Bumpers: Should the Government Ban Crib Bumpers?
  • Response
    Response: pictures of bugs
    Writer, Editor, & Sleep Journalist - The Well Rested Family - Bye-bye, Bumpers: Should the Government Ban Crib Bumpers?
  • Response
    Writer, Editor, & Sleep Journalist - The Well Rested Family - Bye-bye, Bumpers: Should the Government Ban Crib Bumpers?
  • Response
    Writer, Editor, & Sleep Journalist - The Well Rested Family - Bye-bye, Bumpers: Should the Government Ban Crib Bumpers?
  • Response
    Writer, Editor, & Sleep Journalist - The Well Rested Family - Bye-bye, Bumpers: Should the Government Ban Crib Bumpers?
  • Response
    Response: Jared Londry
    Writer, Editor, & Sleep Journalist - The Well Rested Family - Bye-bye, Bumpers: Should the Government Ban Crib Bumpers?

Reader Comments (5)

It bothers me tremendously when the government makes laws telling me how to keep my children safe. Here is another example of time wasted passing a law that should be the parents discretion. I don't mind suggestions, but they get ridiculous with how much say they have with how I raise my children. They are MY kids, not the governments.

November 10, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterNikki Speck

1. I like what Nikki has to say and 2. I am a fan of the bumpers! My daughter is such a tosser and turner that if the bumpers weren't there she'd for sure have a bruise or two from the sides of the crib. I know the risks of having them in the crib so I do/have done my best to keep a close eye on her w/ a video baby monitor etc.. I have seen her step on hers now that she is older to try and climb but she is 2 and nearing her transition to a big girl bed. I do think this matter should be left at the discretion of the parent. . .

November 10, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterKimberly Wyckoff

I agree with the previous commenters. This is ridiculous. Ok, how many kids slept with crib bumpers and had no problem? In general, an infant (the ones who are at risk of being smothered) don't move much so unless a care giver is placing the infants face up against the bumper this should not be an issue. People should be aware of the risks and decide for themselves. I for one have always used a thin bumper (there is to climbing advantage on ours) and had no problems. The bumper has been helpful for us once the baby starts moving around in bed to protect heads from minor bangs and bumps (my kids have always liked to wedge themselves on the corner,,,at an age where smothering from a light blanket or bumper is no longer a fear). Additionally, the bumper provides a little privacy or secluded space for a sleeping baby; giving them a more peaceful rest (especially when the baby shares space with siblings who may move about he room). Seriously, the government needs to spend time working on bigger issues.

November 10, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterAnna

Thanks for your thoughts, ladies! I think every family should make their decision based on their own child's SIDS risk profile, based on the evidence-based risk factors that exist for SIDS. But such individualized advice is tough to hand out, so it's easier for governments just to make a blanket recommendation. But as long as retailers keep selling them, I predict people will keep buying them. It will be interesting.

November 10, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterMalia Jacobson

It's funny, because I feel ok with the government getting involved with what retailers can sell if it is causing deaths to babies, but I do still use our crib bumper. I guess I've had a hard time seeing what the risks would be since it's pretty thin and breathable, but does keep him from looking all around the room (which I know he'd do) and from all the bumps I'm sure he'd have. When he was under 1, we always used the video monitor, and now that he's older, I don't worry as much even though now he's also got a pillow, blanket, and stuffed animals, too. But yeah, with all the hype, there's a good chance I'll skip the bumper for our next baby and not take the chance. Because, probably, if I don't start out with it, neither of us will feel as dependent on it. S/he probably won't make the habit of sleeping right against the slats if there's nothing soft there, and looking around the room won't be a distraction because it's the same thing every day. And yes, it's cute, but certainly that shouldn't be a reason for keeping it.

November 17, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterJoy

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Post:
 
Some HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>